Authentic Pizza & Italian Dining in St John IN

Family Restaurant Near Lake Hills Plaza & Wicker Memorial Park

Welcome to John’s Pizzeria

John’s Pizzeria St John IN brings over 80 years of Italian tradition to every meal. Located near Lake Hills Plaza and Wicker Memorial Park, we serve classic pizzas, pastas, and Italian sandwiches made from scratch daily. Our family-friendly atmosphere and warm service make every visit memorable. Whether dining in or ordering for an event, John’s Pizzeria is your go-to spot for authentic Italian flavor in St John IN.

Our Signature Dishes

Breadsticks in a basket with a red and white checkered liner on a wooden table.

Appetizers

Crispy, savory appetizers made fresh daily, timelessly perfect for sharing with friends and family.

Sandwich with white cheese, greens, and paper wrapping, on a plate outdoors.

Sandwiches

Hearty sandwiches on homemade bread, crafted with fresh ingredients for delicious, satisfying meals daily.

Close-up of pizza with tomatoes, mushrooms, and white cheese.

Pizzas

Handcrafted pizzas baked to perfection, using family recipes and fresh ingredients for unmatched flavor.

Breadsticks in a basket with a red and white checkered liner on a wooden table.

Salads

Crispy, savory appetizers made fresh daily, timelessly perfect for sharing with friends and family.

Close-up of pizza with tomatoes, mushrooms, and white cheese.

Pasta

Handcrafted pizzas baked to perfection, using family recipes and fresh ingredients for unmatched flavor.

John’s Pizzeria Is the Taste You’ve Been Craving

In St. John IN, John’s Pizzeria continues a proud family legacy of handcrafted Italian cooking. For decades, we’ve served hand-tossed pizzas, fresh pasta, and homemade bread made daily from the same cherished recipes that started it all. Our preservative-free sauces, locally sourced toppings, and family-style portions bring people together around the table. Located near Lake Hills Plaza and Wicker Memorial Park, our St. John pizzeria offers a warm dine-in experience and easy delivery options, making every meal a memory worth savoring.

Why Locals Love Us